"Disatu sisi, kebijakan BLT ini mungkin akan memberikan dampak positif bagi masyarakat miskin. Akan tetapi disisi yang lain kebijakan BLT ini memiliki dampak negatif yakni kebijakan ini akan berdampak negatif pada perilaku dan karakter masyarakat. Kebijakan ini sangat riskan menciptakan karakter masyarakat yang salalu dimanja dan menjadi bangsa 'peminta-minta'," kata tokoh masyarakat Rengasdengklok, Bambang, kepada RAKA, Jumat (24/4) siang.
Selain itu, permasalahan efektifitas dan efisiensi kebijakan ini juga sangat diragukan. Apabila melihat tujuan, efisiensi, efektifitas dan dampak yang ditimbulkan oleh kebijakan BLT ini, kebijakan yang diluncurkan pemerintah ini bukanlah kebijakan untuk menaikkan derajat kesejahteraan masyarakat miskin, akan tetapi hanya bertujuan untuk mempertahankan 'image' pemerintah di mata masyarakat. Dilihat dari tujuan kebijakannya, kebijakan BLT bukanlah kebijakan pemerintah untuk membantu dan mengangkat masyarakat (meningkatkan derajat kesejahteraan) miskin melainkan hanya sebuah keputusan politik yang berorientasi untuk mempertahankan 'image' pemerintahan di mata masyarakat.
Kebijakan politis ini terpaksa diambil oleh pemerintah sehubungan semakin dekatnya jadwal pesta demokrasi pemilu 2009. Dilihat dari efisiensi, efektifitas dan dampak yang ditimbulkan oleh kebijakan, kebijakan BLT masih jauh dari kategori efisien dan efektif dalam kerangka menyelesaikan kemiskinan atau bahkan kemiskinan baru yang ditimbulkan oleh kenaikan BBM tersebut. Efisiensi dan efektifitas tersebut sudah dibuktikan dengan pencapaian hasil kebijakan BLT dimasa lalu (Kebijakan BLT tahun 2005) dan melihat pencapaian hasil kebijakan BLT 2005, pemerintah juga sudah merubah kebijakan tersebut menjadi kebijakan Program Keluarga Harapan.
Kalau melihat pada dampak yang akan ditimbulkan oleh kebijakan BLT ini, kebijakan BLT tidak akan memberikan dampak yang signifikan terhadap kondisi masyarakat miskin di Indonesia. Ini disebabkan nominal BLT yang diberikan tidak seimbang dengan kenaikan biaya hidup yang ditanggung oleh masyarakat akibat kenaikan harga BBM. "Coba kita bayangkan, kenaikan BBM tersebut akan mendorong kenaikan biaya untuk pemenuhan kebutuhan dasar masyarakat miskin. Apabila kita membandingkan total kenaikan biaya hidup masyarakat miskin dengan nominal dana BLT yang diberikan, kebijakan ini tidak akan berdampak siginifikan. Apalagi, pemerintah tidak bisa menjamin efesiensi dan efektifitas penggunaan dana BLT yang diberikan kepada masyarakat," jelasnya. (spn)
BLT = the Community's Deception
"On the one hand, this BLT policy will possibly give the positive impact for the poor community." But on the side that was other this BLT policy had the impact of the negative that is this policy will have a negative impact on the behaviour and the character of the community. This policy was very risky created the character of the community that salalu was spoilt and became the 'beggar's' nation, said the public figure Rengasdengklok, Bambang, to RAKA, on Friday early afternoon (24/4).
Moreover, the problem of the effectiveness and this policy efficiency also really was doubted. If seeing the aim, efficiency, the effectiveness and the impact that were caused by this BLT policy, the policy that was launched by this government not the policy of increasing the level of welfare of the poor community, but only aimed at maintaining the 'image' of the government in the eyes of the community. Seen from the aim of his policy, the BLT policy not the policy of the government of helping and appointing the community (increased the level of welfare) poor but only a decision of politics that was oriented to maintain the 'image' of the government in the eyes of the community.
This political policy was forced to be taken by the government in connection with increasingly the proximity of the party schedule of general election democracy 2009. Seen from efficiency, the effectiveness and the impact that were caused by the policy, the BLT policy still far from the efficient and effective category in the framework was completing poverty or even new poverty that were caused by the rise in this FUEL OIL. Efficiency and this effectiveness have been proven with the achievement produced by the BLT policy dimasa then (the BLT policy in 2005) and saw the achievement produced by the BLT policy 2005, the government has also changed this policy of becoming the policy of the Keluarga Harapan Program.
If saw in the impact that will be caused by this BLT policy, the BLT policy will not give the impact that was significant towards the condition for the poor community in Indonesia. This was caused nominal BLT that was given not balanced with the rise in the cost of living that was borne by the community as a result of the price increase of BBM. "Coba was imagined by us, the rise" in "this FUEL OIL will push the rise" in the "cost for the fulfilment" of the "requirement" for the "foundation" of the "poor community." If we compared the total rise in the community's poor cost of living nominally the BLT fund that was given, this policy will not have an impact siginifikan. Moreover, the government could not guarantee efesiensi and the effectiveness of the use of the BLT fund that was given to the community, he explained. (spn)
BLT = the Community's Deception
"On the one hand, this BLT policy will possibly give the positive impact for the poor community." But on the side that was other this BLT policy had the impact of the negative that is this policy will have a negative impact on the behaviour and the character of the community. This policy was very risky created the character of the community that salalu was spoilt and became the 'beggar's' nation, said the public figure Rengasdengklok, Bambang, to RAKA, on Friday early afternoon (24/4).
Moreover, the problem of the effectiveness and this policy efficiency also really was doubted. If seeing the aim, efficiency, the effectiveness and the impact that were caused by this BLT policy, the policy that was launched by this government not the policy of increasing the level of welfare of the poor community, but only aimed at maintaining the 'image' of the government in the eyes of the community. Seen from the aim of his policy, the BLT policy not the policy of the government of helping and appointing the community (increased the level of welfare) poor but only a decision of politics that was oriented to maintain the 'image' of the government in the eyes of the community.
This political policy was forced to be taken by the government in connection with increasingly the proximity of the party schedule of general election democracy 2009. Seen from efficiency, the effectiveness and the impact that were caused by the policy, the BLT policy still far from the efficient and effective category in the framework was completing poverty or even new poverty that were caused by the rise in this FUEL OIL. Efficiency and this effectiveness have been proven with the achievement produced by the BLT policy dimasa then (the BLT policy in 2005) and saw the achievement produced by the BLT policy 2005, the government has also changed this policy of becoming the policy of the Keluarga Harapan Program.
If saw in the impact that will be caused by this BLT policy, the BLT policy will not give the impact that was significant towards the condition for the poor community in Indonesia. This was caused nominal BLT that was given not balanced with the rise in the cost of living that was borne by the community as a result of the price increase of BBM. "Coba was imagined by us, the rise" in "this FUEL OIL will push the rise" in the "cost for the fulfilment" of the "requirement" for the "foundation" of the "poor community." If we compared the total rise in the community's poor cost of living nominally the BLT fund that was given, this policy will not have an impact siginifikan. Moreover, the government could not guarantee efesiensi and the effectiveness of the use of the BLT fund that was given to the community, he explained. (spn)
